Search: Web        
powered by
Le Templar: What I Know ~

Archive for the '“birthers”' Tag

Federal judge to ‘birthers’: Go away

October 29th, 2009, 3:19 pm by Le Templar

The Tribune has receive a sizable number of letters to the editor in the past few months about the claims that President Barack Obama isn’t a natural-born citizen as required by the Constitution (Art. II, Sect. 1). So they claim he never was eligible to be elected or sworn in president. A number of federal lawsuits have been filed around the country on issue, with the arguments getting more convoluted with the passage of time. But every one of the lawsuits have been dismissed, and the U.S. Supreme Court has refused to consider any of them.

Lately, the most virulent believers of Obama’s ineligibility, often referred to as “birthers” by critics (such as myself), have been pining on their hopes on U.S. District Judge David O. Carter of California. Carter didn’t immediately dismiss the lawsuit like other judges. He heard arguments and considered evidence, so the birthers thought they finally would get their day in court.

Nope. The judge ended the case today. Carter’s speaks to why every lawsuit has been a waste of time and money. The Constitution spells out how a sitting president can be removed from office, and the courts have no authority to do so, Carter says. If Obama somehow wasn’t born in Hawaii or if he somehow gave up his U.S. citizenship as a child, it would be Congress’ task to impeach him. However, even staunch conservatives such as Rep. Trent Franks, R-Ariz., reject the birthers’ position in light of the various evidence confirming Obama’s natural-born citizenship.

Trent Franks: Obama is a citizen

August 28th, 2009, 1:37 pm by Le Templar

frankstrentwebRep. Trent Franks, R-Ariz., is managing some damage control after an Arizona newspaper erroneously reported that he was considering a lawsuit to challenge the natural-born citizenship of President Barack Obama. In fact, Franks says in a statement that he did consider a lawsuit last year when the question about Obama’s eligibility was first raised. But Franks’ own research into the matter convinced him that Obama was born in Hawaii and always was eligible to be president:

“…the fact that we found [the evidence that Pres. Obama is a natural-born, American citizen] made it impossible for me in good conscience to go into a big lawsuit.”

Franks explains the flap started when a reporter for the Mohave Daily News misinterpreted his comments at a local town hall meeting. Franks doesn’t beat up the reporter for this “honest mistake” and gives the reporter credit for writing a follow-up story explaining his actual position.

However, the original story was picked up instantly across the nation by news sites and political blogs, in part because the conspiracy theorists known as “birthers” refuse to go away. Politico’s version was one of its top 5 stories on Monday because of the novelty of a member of Congress suggesting that the current president should have been barred by the Constitution from running for election.

But Franks says it’s false, all false. Franks might be “terrified” by Obama’s policies, but he no longer doubts that Obama is a red-blooded American.

Of course, this doesn’t explain why Franks couldn’t communicate his views clearly last week when confronted with a “birther” question, or why he believes Obama still needs to produce a different birth certificate.

ADVERTISEMENT